|
Following the
signing of Indo-Myanmar Border Trade on
January 21st, 1994 and operationalised on
April 12, 1995 through Moreh Border, trading
activities have assumed importance in the
State of Manipur. Indo-Myanmar border was
formally opened by the Commerce Ministry of
the both the countries. Subsequently, 22
items have been allowed as exchangeable by
the residents across the border. The main
role of the Department of Commerce and
Industries is to act as a link agent for
promotion of border trade between India and
Myanmar. It can be said that Indo-Myanmar
Trade can help in increasing the economic
growth of the economy of Manipur.
Northeastern States of India altogether
share 1643 km long with Indo-Myanmar border.
Arunachal Pradesh, Mizoram, Manipur and
Nagaland share 520 kms, 510 kms, 398 kms and
215 kms long respectively with Myanmar
borders.
This paper is the result of an attempt made
to examine the nature and scope of trading
activities across the borders between
Northeast India and Myanmar against the
theoretical background of international
trade between the two countries. Attempts
have been made to understand as to whether
there exists any basis for trade in terms of
compatibility between the resource structure
of the north-eastern region and the demand
structure of the neighboring countries.
It would be quite relevant here to examine
that trade is an engine of economic growth.
It is widely admitted that low income
countries are characterized by small size of
market. The small size of market fails to
absorb sufficient volume of output that
leads to low inducement to invest.
International trade can expand the size of
market because it increases the inducement
to invest, promote the growth of income and
saving through more efficient allocation of
resources. It also helps to transform the
subsistence sector into a monetized sector
by providing market for farm produce and
raises the income level and standard of
living of the people. International trade
also leads to specialization and division of
labor. When a country specializes in the
production of a few goods, it exports those
goods that have comparative cost advantage
in exchange for what others can produce at a
lower cost. Thus it gains from trade and
there is increase in national income, which
in turn, raises the level of output and the
growth rate of economy. Hence higher level
of output and income achieved through trade
tends to break viscous cycle of poverty and
promote economic development.
Many economists pointed out that
Indo-Myanmar Trade can play a vital role in
promoting speedy development of Manipur. In
this connection, B.K. Sharma & S.N. Goswami
(2000) pointed out that with the
liberalization of the border trade, the
activities like trade and commerce, banking
and insurance services transport and
communication, warehousing facilities, etc.,
would be increased in Northeastern region
which in turn would accelerate the economic
activities of the region. Border trade can
also create external economies which could
be reaped by the State. In this regard,
Baruah (2000) supported that the decision of
the SAARC nations to have a regional
liberalization to move towards a South Asian
Free Trade (SAFTA) by the end of the year
2000 A.D would definitely have certain
positive implications on the economic
prospect of Northeastern regions India
having about 98 per cent of its border with
neighboring countries- Bhutan, Bangladesh,
Myanmar and China.
Following the liberalization of border
trade, the volume of trade has risen
significantly as compared with pre-border
trade liberalization. For example, the trade
between India and Myanmar rose from Rs. 894
million in 1989-90 to Rs. 2828 million in
1997-98. India’s exports consist mainly of
cement, cycle, drugs and pharmaceuticals,
auto parts and accessories and cotton yarn.
It was estimated that border trade amounted
to Rs. 1600 crore per year (S.B.Singh &
Goswami, 2000). Major items entering India
are blankets, electronic goods, betel nuts,
pulses, teaks, teak, groundnuts, iron scrap,
gold, silver and precious stones. Major
items entering Myanmar from India cotton
yarn, cycles, food products, textiles,
kerosene, diesel and drugs and
pharmaceuticals. A study made by Indian
Institute of Foreign Trade (IIFT) reveals
high volume of informal trade on illegal
basis with neighboring countries. It has
estimated at around Rs. 600 crore value per
annum in terms of exports from Assam,
Meghalaya and Tripura to Bangladesh and
Myanmar through Moreh and Champai and Lungwa
in Nagaland is estimated at Rs. 2000 crore
per annum. Although the large volume of
illegal trade is a problem, it exhibits
export potential of the Northeastern region.
According to the recent annual report, 2001,
International Narcotics Control Bureau, the
1643-km Indo-Myanmar border has been
utilized as a transit point between the
Golden Triangle and the Golden Crescent. The
amount of ephedrine seized in the border
areas rose from 1000 kgs in 1998 to 7000 kgs
in 1999. With the opening of 160-km long
Tamu-Kalewa-Kalemya road the trade could
increase significantly for local products.
Recently, the volume of export and import
for Manipur has been significantly
increased. For instance, the volume of
export recorded an amount of Rs. 25, 16,
67,199.00 while the volume of import
registered an amount of Rs. 37, 16,
39,991.00 in 1997-98. (Custom House,
Shillong). The exports mainly consist of
Mustard/Rape seed, Pulses and Brans, Fresh
Vegetables, Fruits, Garlic, Onion, Chilies,
Spices, Bamboo, Minor Forest Products
excluding Teak, Betel Nuts and Leaves, Food
Items for Local Consumption, Tobacco,
Tomato, Reed Broom, Sesame, Resin, Coriander
Seeds, Soya bean, Ginger, Roaster Sunflower,
Seeds and any other commodities as may be
agreed between the two sides.
Development of road transport will also
promote travel and tourism between the two
neighbors. Both the countries have agreed to
open four checkpoints for increasing trade
between the two countries. These include the
Pangsau Pass, Paletwa, Lungwa-Yanyong and
Pangsha-Pangnyo. This would make official
the trade between the two countries. It has
been decided to develop banking, immigration
and customs facilities at the border
checkpoints. The land opening could also
make possible India in reaching ASEAN
countries through land front line because
Myanmar is the only ASEAN country having a
land border with India. Interaction with
Myanmar has received an impetus with the
initiation of Bangladesh, India, Myanmar,
Sri Lanka, and Thailand Economic Cooperation
and Mekong-Ganga Cooperation. Under the
initiation of NEC, the Rail India Technical
and Economic Service (RITES), New Delhi had
visited Moreh during March, 1996 to assess
potential for creating infrastructural
facility and submitted a consultancy
proposal to NEC for establishment of an EPZ
near the hills of Kondong Lairenbi Temple
about 3 Kms. from Moreh on NH No.39.
The proposed project report will consider
facility relating to Power, Transport,
Warehousing/Handling, Research, Development
and Training Institutes, Telecommunication,
Civic facilities, Business Centre,
Employment Generation Institutional
arrangements and linkage, Financing
Agencies. The Stale Government has also
approached the North Eastern Council for
assistance in setting up one EPZ project but
so far there is no positive response. The
total cost of EPZ is estimated at Rs.100.00
crores. H.E Jaswant Singh also recommended
the enthusiasm of his Government to assist
with the Myanmar Government in accomplishing
other mutually useful infrastructural
projects including the proposed Tamanthi
Hydro-Electric Project near the
India-Myanmar border across Naga land, the
proposed Kaladan River navigation, Road and
Pipeline Project in the Rakhine State
providing a link to southern Mizoram state
in India and India's North East as a whole.
Dr. Khin Maung in his, A New Chapter in
Indo-Myanmar Relations advocated that "In
the fields of trade and industry there are
ample openings for Indian investors and
entrepreneurs. Myanmar people have a
traditional liking for Indian textile goods
especially pulicat and calico materials for
men's wear and women's wear respectively.
There are Indian leather goods, light
machineries for domestic use and heavy
machineries especially for rail train
locomotives and carriages and ships that had
made their brand names known in Myanmar.
What about Indian luxuries - cosmetics,
costume jewellery, finery and what not that
have both attraction and competitiveness in
any market? There is also the entertainment
world in which Indian film, music, song and
dance have enjoyed their heyday in Myanmar.
Reciprocally Myanmar agricultural products
like pulses, mineral products like precious
stones, ruby & sapphire and other
semi-precious stones and many other products
have their market in India. Such are the
fields the new generations of Indian and
Myanmar businessmen, industrialists and
investors should explore in consultation
with old generations in both countries that
have vast experiences."
In the light of the above, it is quite
evident that there is large scope for
increasing the volume of export for Manipur
with the removal of various existing
infrastructural constraints. The economy of
Manipur can also maximize the net state
domestic product by increasing the share of
trade. This can be possible by specializing
in the production of few goods which have
comparative advantage and import those goods
which have comparative disadvantage. A State
intervention in this area for providing a
congenial atmosphere is desirable for making
Investment friendly and at the same time a
strong political will is highly needed.
*** The author has a Ph.D. in Economics
from Manipur University, Imphal, Manipur,
India. His specialization is in Poverty
Economics. He writes on various topics
relevant to the state economy and its
relationship with the neighboring states and
countries.
*** The
author can be reached at
thiyam_bharat@yahoo.com
|