|
The then Prime
Minister of India late Nehru called present
Manipur as ‘Jewel of the East’.
Topographically Manipur can be divided into
two i.e. the valley and the hill. The Meitei
community, who are in majority numerically,
inhabits the valley and on the other hand
the tribal, who are in minority, inhabits
the hill. The valley part of Manipur was
once a princely State, ruled by the
Maharajas; it has a rich cultural and
literary tradition. Later on, the Meitei
cultural belief systems were effectively
influenced by the Hindu Vaishnavism belief
system, and as a result it has brought a
paradigm shift in the belief system of the
Meitei people. And today, to a large extent
the Meiteis consider Hinduism as their
religion and practice contentedly.
Thus, the idea and
concept of purity and Hindu Brahmanical
practices were imbibed by the Meitei people
thereby, considered the hill inhabitance
people mostly the Nagas and the Kukis as
‘Hao’ or uncivilized people. The Hills of
Manipur are inhabited by the so-called ‘Hao’
or uncivilized people i.e. the Nagas and the
Kukis who proudly claimed that they are
settling in their indigenous land, which was
given to them by their forefather. They also
happily practice their old age traditional
cultural practices and later on they were
converted into Christianity, and today, they
also proudly professed Christianity as their
religion.
The hill people inhabited on a hilltop with
numerous villages are governed and ruled by
the village elders or the village chiefs.
Thus, unlike the valley this part of the
land was not ruled by the Meitei Maharajas
at any point of time, but governed by the
village elder or village chief through a
democratic procedure. The Meitei Maharajas
failed to rule the hill areas because,
probably because it was not possible for the
Maharajas to climb the hill and do not
perceived the need for controlling the hill
areas after all it is inhabited by the
uncivilized people. Thus, considered not
important for both geographical and
demographic consideration. But today the
attitude has changed and it has a different
image.
Gradually, this once princely State was also
annex and merged into the India Union along
with the other Northeastern States, thus
ending the long age traditional Maharajas
rule and became part of the Indian Union.
Later on, the hill areas along with the
Valley merged into Indian Union and formed
the present Manipur State. In both the
valley and the hill, the British and the
Indian ruler did not ascertain the people’s
consent at the time of merger. As a result
people especially from the hill and
particularly the Nagas strongly agitated
against the merger of their land into the
valley and subsequently into the Indian
Union. The equal amount of resistance was
not visible in the valley at that time. The
Nagas still committed and continues their
struggle till date.
Today, however, the neo conservative
thinking Meitei community are regretting for
what their predecessor have done in the past
(i.e. cultural assimilation and merging to
the Indian Union). Thus, attempts are being
made to restore back the old age rich
political and cultural tradition, and as the
outcome of their attempt incidents like
banning of the Hindi movies in the valley of
Manipur, burning of the Bengali script books
and an attempt to replaced it by their own
script and denouncing the Indian state etc.
are some of the emotional regrets manifested
by the Meitei people in recent times. A kind
of Cultural Revolution is on in the Valley
of Manipur at present.
The valley people seem to have woken up from
their sleep and today, they are trying to
reclaim back their past glory and ironically
blame the Indian state and the Hindu
religion and partly to the Nagas for their
political misfortune. Hence, the
consequences like the banning of Hindi
movies in the valley and followed by
attacking the Government buildings and
public library etc. Vehement agitation
against the removal of Armed Forces Special
Power Act (AFSPA) is one area where the
Meiteis try to get mileage and empathy from
non-Meiteis. All these attacks in a way
manifested the frustration of the valley
people against the symbols of the Indian
state power and forces. Some Meitei assert
that they wanted to restore back their
freedom and independent Kingdom of the past.
In this entire episode the hill people seem
to have shown their outmost restrain for not
going against the Meitei people. I say this
because the government building or the
public library properties etc. does not
solely belong to the Meiteis but it is also
equally the property of others/non-Meitei as
well. This in a way reflects the Meiteis
intolerance attitudes towards the other
communities’ rights and their existence in
the present Manipur state.
Again, the agitation that triggered in the
Valley in the recent years following the
Government of India announcement that the
Indo-NSCN (IM) ceasefire be extended to
Manipur state left the entire state with
total anarchy and chaos. And the subsequence
provocative slogan against the Nagas like
‘there are no Nagas in Manipur, all the hill
people are Meiteis etc. and the subsequent
declaration by the Government of Manipur
that the 18th June be declared as ‘Martyr’s’
day and hence declaring as state holiday.
This not only expresses their sense of
intolerance towards the minority in the
state but it is also a sheer expression of
their fear and insecurity of their existence
in the Indian state hence asserting the
majoritarianism force seem to be the only
option left. This declaration was however,
feverishly opposed by All Naga Students
Association of Manipur (ANSAM) and called
for a month long economic blockade in the
two National Highway i.e. NH 39 and NH 53.
The paradox is that the Meiteis are in
majority in Manipur when it comes to the
numerical demographical factors but in the
geographical terms they just has merely 10
per cent of the total land in the present
State and the rest belong to the Nagas and
the Kukis. Today, Meiteis are so concerned
about the others' land and when to the
extent of giving their life and not even
sure whether the Nagas exist and own those
land in Manipur or not. It is high time that
the Meiteis should start respecting the
other people and the land and not just
respecting the land alone, which they have
done in the past. In doing this the Meiteis
will be also respected by other people. The
matter of the fact is that Meitei cannot
afford to lose the neighborhood of the Nagas
and the Kukis. Thus, if they continue to
assert their majoritarianism power without
respecting and recognizing the presence of
the minority then the minority can also
effectively play their parts, which can
equally cause the damage. We have witnessed
this dramatic politics played out by the
Meiteis and the Nagas over the years.
Meiteis should not act as if they are blind
rather they should open their social eyes
and admit the reality. The Meitei should not
continue to ignore the presence of the Nagas
of Manipur in the future.
The majority of the Meitei’s attitudes of we
love your land and the resources but really
not the people have made the non-Meiteis
difficult to live together in one political
unit. The mass rapes carried out by
non-tribal UGs in the Churachandpur district
are some of the worse incident that took
place in the civilized world. The latest
hill house tax collected by the United Naga
Council (UNC) and attempted to submit to the
Central government is a clear testimony that
the Nagas of Manipur can no longer be part
of Manipur state. The matter of the fact is
that it is not just the house tax and the
money but more importantly Nagas do not feel
worthy to be a part of that state. Again,
the UNC have directed all the private
schools in the four Naga hill district of
Manipur to affiliate in the Nagaland Board
of Secondary School (NBSC). All these
reflect the total failure of the Manipur
state legitimacy to rule over the people.
This is nothing but the reflection and the
outcome of the failed and intolerance state
towards the minority community in the state.
The latest ongoing agitation by the All
Tribal Students’ Union Manipur (ATSUM)
regarding the failure of the State in
fulfilling the 33% reservation of job in the
Government services for the tribal community
is another example of the repeated failed
story of the state towards the tribal
community in the state. According to the
ATSUM released in the Morung Newspaper dated
29th June stated that“ the State Government
conventional reservation of 33% for SC/ST
has rooms for manipulations and encourage
the recruitment practices of Adhoc/casual/muster-roll/work-charge/part-time/contract/substitution
so as to avoid reservation norms.”
It is also
pertinent to see that the Manipur University
is presently under processes of recruiting
21 professors, 23 posts of reader and 23
lecturer posts where only one post is
reserved for ST and only two reserved for
SC, this is a clear indication of violation
of the reservation of the State’s own
policy. All these categorically testify how
majority community in the State often takes
away even the very rights of the minority
community, overlooked and deprived by the
Government. Under this circumstance it is
crucial to see the life of the tribal
community in Manipur, who often live with
insecurity in their own state. Today, it
would not be wrong to say that this ‘Jewel
of the East’ has turned into a ‘scandalous
State’. |